| YEAR | Men's Division 1 | Men's Division 2 | Men's Division 3 | Women's Division 1 | Women's Division 2 |
| 1992 | Iowa State | Toledo | |||
| 1993 | North Dakota State | Buffalo State | |||
| 1994 | North Dakota State | Ferris State | |||
| 1995 | Ohio | Colorado State | |||
| 1996 | Ohio | Western Michigan | |||
| 1997 | Ohio | Life University | |||
| 1998 | Penn State | Life University | |||
| 1999 | Vacated | Life University | |||
| 2000 | Penn State | Miami (OH) | Butler | ||
| 2001 | Penn State | Life University | Wyoming | St. Cloud State | |
| 2002 | Penn State | Life University | Robert Morris (PA) | Wisconsin | |
| 2003 | Penn State | Colorado | Muskegon CC | Michigan State | |
| 2004 | Ohio | Oakland | Calvin College | Wisconsin | |
| 2005 | Illinois | Michigan State | Colorado | Robert Morris (IL) | |
| 2006 | Rhode Island | Oakland | Wright State | Lindenwood | |
| 2007 | Oakland | Michigan State | Kennesaw State | Robert Morris (IL) | St. Scholastica |
| 2008 | Illinois | Davenport | California University (PA) | Lindenwood | Rainy River CC |
| 2009 | Lindenwood | Davenport | Saginaw Valley State | Lindenwood | Rainy River CC |
| 2010 | Lindenwood | Davenport | Saginaw Valley State | Lindenwood | Northeastern |
| 2011 | Davenport | Grand Valley State | College of the Canyons | Michigan State | Rainy River CC |
| 2012 | Delaware | Florida Gulf Coast | Adrian | Northeastern | Wisconsin-Stout |
| 2013 | Minot State | Michigan State | Adrian | Minnesota | West Chester |
| 2014 | Arizona State | New Hampshire | Adrian | Miami (OH) | Iowa State |
| 2015 | Central Oklahoma | New York University | Michigan State | Liberty | North Dakota State |
| 2016 | Lindenwood | Florida Gulf Coast | Oakland | Miami (OH) | Minnesota-Duluth |
| 2017 | Central Oklahoma | New York University | Aquinas College | Miami (OH) | Lakehead |
| 2018 | Adrian College | Florida Gulf Coast | Hope College | Liberty | Lakehead |
| 2019 | Minot State | Florida Gulf Coast | Sault College | Liberty | Assiniboine CC |
| 2020 | No Tournament | No Tournament | No Tournament | No Tournament | No Tournament |
| 2021 | Adiran College | University of Mary | Hope College | Liberty | No Tournament |
| 2022 | Lindenwood | University of Mary | Hope College | Liberty | Assiniboine CC |
